Jump to content

Strut binding or something?


Red Nightmare

Recommended Posts

Often when I go around turns, especially turning right, it sounds like a dry eratic popping noise in the front end.

Tonight was jacking up the passenger front to do some brake work, and as the car was being raised, the wheel (par the strut) was like popping as it expanded instead of a fluid motion.

When the car is no the ground, when I test the shocks, they seem OK. Bounce the car a couple times by hand and it quickly regains stability instead of bouncing several times.

 

Anyways is there anything i could do to really remedy that dry popping noise? I am tempted to throw grease or something on it but i guess that isn't the answer. Does that "cartridge" in the strut have anything to do with that?

Most important, is this something that would decide to fall apart when driving and fuck up my car and life, much like say if a ball joint gave way?

Thanks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ball joints make a popping noise. I don't think that is what you have.

 

Do you have any issues with memory steer?

 

My Grand prix would make a popping noise when turning. It was from the strut coil plate. It was worn out and it was causing memory steer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I second that. if you jack up the front end and the steering wheel is still hard to turn and it pops as you turn the wheel then it is the strut bearings. They are at the top of the springs under the towers. They get all contamination in them and the grease dries out. The popping noise is the spring overcoming the bearing and kicking back into place.

When the strut bearings are bad the springs are turning as you turn the wheels. Not supposed to happen. The springs are supposed to be stationary.

Also bad for the alignment, power steering, and springs. Typically if one side is bad they are both bad.

Check your balljoints also though. Jack up one side at a time. Grab the tire at 4oclock and 11oclock and see if there is play. If there is then you know you have bad balljoints

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I second that. if you jack up the front end and the steering wheel is still hard to turn and it pops as you turn the wheel then it is the strut bearings. They are at the BOTTOM of the springs BETWEEN THE SPRING AND THE KNUCKLE. They get all contamination in them and the grease dries out. The popping noise is the spring overcoming the bearing and kicking back into place.

When the strut bearings are bad the springs are turning as you turn the wheels. Not supposed to happen. The springs are supposed to be stationary.

Also bad for the alignment, power steering, and springs. Typically if one side is bad they are both bad.

Check your balljoints also though. Jack up one side at a time. Grab the tire at 4oclock and 11oclock and see if there is play. If there is then you know you have bad balljoints

fixed

 

and.. on our cars, I detect bad ball joints by placing a crowbar between the knuckle and the control arm and seeing if I can force the control arm to move away from the knuckle. sure fire detection everytime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember what I forgot... you can check the condition of the bearings without even taking anything apart. Reach into the wheel well and grab the plate at the bottom of the spring. Forceably rotate it side to side. you should be able to rotate it, although the spring will fight you and should return it to the centered position. You can raise the car for sufficient clearance if needed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I will have to check those plates...

The ball joints are good though - I had to replace the driver side one about a month ago, it had a lot of play when prying. Fun job removing the rivets. the passenger one was replaced at some point and still seems to be good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Greased the passenger ball joint just to eliminate that as a possibility.

Anyways the plates on the bottom of the spring turn smooth yet firmly.

 

Noise is not really caused by steering per se, but as we know when a car is turning there is a bit of rolling movement just cause of weight shift. Noise is kind of a binding clunk. Sometimes I can get it to make this clunking noise when I back up or forward quickly.

 

Strut binding or something? Thing is when I bounce the front end it doesn't make any noise and returns to normal position quick instead of bouncing a lot.

 

When I inspect the front end - control arms don't look like they are gonna fall off, ball joints are good, steering components seem good.

Sorry this is kind of vague, I know it is one of those "It makes a noise when... what could it be?.." questions that drive people crazy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...