Lysander Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 Was working on a friend's exhaust last night (1995 Monte Carlo) and discovered a big problem. What he thought was a noisy strut turned out to be the sheet metal at the top of the strut tower tearing away around the strut mount. The body has rusted and separated around the outside of the strut mount, and a crack is working it's way inboard to complete the job. Has anyone fixed this type of problem on a w-body? Would swapping to a monoleaf rear suspension help? Do they make patch kits similar to those available for Chrysler minivans? Many thanks, Justin Quote
GOT2B GM Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 could weld a custom patch panel in to buy some more time out of the car, but honestly..... Quote
Lysander Posted August 10, 2009 Author Report Posted August 10, 2009 LOL! That's what I said. It seems that the car is a crappy wrapper for a nice drivetrain at the moment, it has a low mileage supercharged V6 in it with a good transmission and suspension. It may be time to buy a rust-free shell with a blown motor and swap everything over. Quote
94GPGTP Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 could weld a custom patch panel in to buy some more time out of the car, but honestly..... That crusher has rims!! Quote
jeremy Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 That crusher has rims!! it has tires too.... Quote
CSI_MuNkY Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 I think that car has a future with Cash For Clunkers... Hell they might not even want it Jamie Quote
xtremerevolution Posted August 10, 2009 Report Posted August 10, 2009 Get another car with a blown motor and swap it, or just junk it. Seriously, that's not worth fixing. You couldn't go with a monoleaf as the strut tower will still take some force from the shock itself. However, I do want to see some pictures of the damage. Quote
BXX Posted August 11, 2009 Report Posted August 11, 2009 Get another car with a blown motor and swap it, or just junk it. Seriously, that's not worth fixing. You couldn't go with a monoleaf as the strut tower will still take some force from the shock itself. However, I do want to see some pictures of the damage. since when do our cars have shocks? Quote
1990lumina Posted August 11, 2009 Report Posted August 11, 2009 Get another car with a blown motor and swap it, or just junk it. Seriously, that's not worth fixing. You couldn't go with a monoleaf as the strut tower will still take some force from the shock itself. However, I do want to see some pictures of the damage. since when do our cars have shocks? In the Suzuki world at least anything with a spring around it is a strut - and anything without is a shock. Quote
Lysander Posted August 11, 2009 Author Report Posted August 11, 2009 Not the car in question, but similar damage posted by another member on ClubGP Quote
Lysander Posted August 11, 2009 Author Report Posted August 11, 2009 I think the cammed L67 / 4T65e-HD we swapped into this car might end up in his Fiero, or maybe another Monte I don't know. I'll post back when he gets an estimate on the repair. If it were mine I'd have a junkyard torch out the top of a good strut tower, about 8" tall, hammer it up into the rotted tower, and bolt / weld it in. That way the patch would be captured by the tapering sheet metal and the welds / fasteners wouldn't have to be as robust. Quote
slick Posted August 11, 2009 Report Posted August 11, 2009 Wow, screw that. I'd park it, and start tearing it all apart for the scrapyard. Quote
rockfangd Posted August 16, 2009 Report Posted August 16, 2009 my best friends 95 lumina did the same thing as that but i think the crack spread down the tower also. MY 94 olds never did that I am hoping i dont have that kind of problem on my 2000 lumina. I wouldnt put much work into that. Also check the rear trailing arm body mounts which are also extremely common in that year and others Quote
DaveB Posted February 20, 2012 Report Posted February 20, 2012 Any updates from the OP? I have the same problem on my 1999 Lumina 4 door. Murhpy's law that I just redid the head gaskets and lim, and installed a car stereo. Runs great and I sure would like to keep it for many more years. I scoured the internet during my lunch break and haven't found any evidence that anyone has ever fixed this problem. Quote
3pt1lumina Posted February 20, 2012 Report Posted February 20, 2012 Just battled this with my white Lumina. 97, 177k. was getting bad. Before it got undriveable I traded it in, got $2k for it. As much as I hated to part with it, I still have 2 that are rot free. And while I hate to say this, it's true. It's just a Lumina. So in the realm of things, trying to fix it would just be putting good money after bad, these are worth $1500 tops, rust or no rust. Drive it until it breaks through, or swap the drivetrain, or sell/trade now while you can. That's my suggestion. Quote
carkhz316 Posted February 20, 2012 Report Posted February 20, 2012 Probably no new news. Their really isn't an option to fix, short of aformentioned custom patch panels and whatnot, which really REALLY isn't worth the time and effort for most as their car is either a DD or beater. Quote
GaPrix Posted February 21, 2012 Report Posted February 21, 2012 I've seen something like this fixed before, the guy had it all cut and welded new metal in, no clue how much it ran him, but it was done pretty well. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.